The 6 best pizzas around Vail Valley

From wood-fired perfection to late-night slices, pizza in Vail Valley comes in all forms—and locals have strong opinions about which pies rise above the rest. Whether you crave a thin crust loaded with toppings or a rustic Neapolitan-style masterpiece, there’s no shortage of passion for this universally loved comfort food. In this year’s Best of Vail Valley contest, voters celebrated the pizzerias that bring skill, creativity, and heart to every slice.

Alpine Pizza Company captures the laid-back energy of Lionshead with pizzas crafted from scratch and baked to golden perfection. The menu features both classic combinations and creative builds, all made with high-quality ingredients that let each flavor shine. Its welcoming atmosphere and convenient slope-side location make it a favorite stop after a day on the mountain.

Gondola Pizza in Avon has been a family staple for years, known for hand-tossed crusts, generous toppings, and a relaxed, friendly vibe. The restaurant offers a full menu of pizzas, subs, and salads, perfect for dine-in meals or takeout nights at home. Its consistency and hometown feel have earned it a loyal following that stretches well beyond the gondola.

Il Mago brings authentic Italian style to Edwards, with wood-fired pizzas that balance tradition and innovation. The restaurant’s attention to detail shows in every pie—from the perfectly blistered crust to the fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Il Mago’s intimate setting and modern approach make it ideal for both a casual lunch and an elegant evening out.

Pickup’s Pizza Company in Eagle keeps things classic, focusing on crowd-pleasing flavors and a community-centered feel. Its hand-tossed pizzas are built with care and served in a space that’s as warm as the oven itself. Known for great service and a menu that’s straightforward but delicious, Pickup’s is the kind of local gem that defines small-town dining at its best.

Flour Power Craft Pizza takes pizza-making seriously, with a craft approach that highlights inventive toppings and artisan dough. This Eagle hotspot specializes in quality over quantity, offering carefully composed pies that appeal to both purists and adventurous eaters. The result is pizza that feels as elevated as it does comforting.

Pazzo’s Pizzeria has become synonymous with pizza in Vail Valley, serving up casual slices and whole pies to generations of locals and visitors. With multiple locations, the pizzeria maintains its friendly, no-frills atmosphere while delivering the kind of consistent flavor that keeps people coming back year after year.