The 5 Best Italian Restaurants Around Vail Valley

Italian food has a way of bringing people together, whether around a table of handmade pasta or over a bottle of wine shared among friends. In Vail Valley, that spirit thrives in restaurants where tradition meets the mountain lifestyle. Locals who voted in this year’s Best of Vail Valley contest honored spots that pair warm hospitality with authentic flavors, proving that a taste of Italy feels right at home in Colorado’s high country.

La Nonna Ristorante Vail is a love letter to Italian cooking. Family-owned and operated, the restaurant draws from generations of culinary tradition to create a menu that emphasizes authenticity and balance. Guests can expect house-made pastas, seasonal ingredients, and an inviting, intimate atmosphere. The dining room’s rustic elegance captures the essence of Italy while remaining unmistakably Vail—sophisticated yet relaxed.

Ristorante Ti Amo has been a local favorite in Avon for years, known for blending classic Italian recipes with a welcoming, family-style approach. The menu spans everything from seafood and veal to rich pasta dishes and fresh salads, all served in a setting that feels both elegant and comfortable. It’s a place where regulars are greeted by name and visitors are treated like old friends.

Zino Ristorante brings modern Italian cuisine to downtown Edwards, offering a stylish yet approachable take on traditional fare. With its open kitchen, wood-fired oven, and lively atmosphere, Zino is as much about the experience as the food. Handmade pastas, fresh seafood, and carefully curated wines make every visit memorable, while the restaurant’s riverside patio adds a scenic touch that locals love.

Fattoria brings farm-to-table philosophy to Italian cooking, celebrating simplicity and quality through seasonal ingredients. Located in Avon, the restaurant’s menu reflects a deep respect for both local produce and classic European technique. From its handmade pastas to its beautifully composed entrees, Fattoria delivers a dining experience that feels refined yet grounded in community.

Tavernetta Vail captures the warmth of Italian hospitality in a refined alpine setting. Known for handmade pasta, thoughtful service, and a carefully curated wine list, the restaurant offers the perfect mix of comfort and sophistication. Its inviting bar area makes it as fitting for a casual glass of wine as for a full-course dinner, embodying the relaxed elegance that defines dining in Vail.

Thanks, ChatGPT.

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.