The 5 Best Consignment Shops (Clothing/Furnishings) Around Vail Valley

Shopping secondhand in Vail Valley isn’t just about finding deals—it’s about uncovering character and sustainability in every purchase. Locals know that consignment shops here carry more than furniture and fashion; they tell the story of mountain life, where quality design and practicality meet. In the Best of Vail Valley readers’ choice contest, voters recognized the shops that make resale shopping stylish, accessible, and eco-conscious.

Holy Toledo in Minturn has been part of the valley’s retail landscape for more than 25 years, curating high-quality consignment pieces with a distinctive mountain flair. The store’s racks feature designer clothing, accessories, and home décor—all carefully selected to fit the area’s casual elegance. Holy Toledo’s friendly staff makes it easy for shoppers to browse at leisure, whether they’re hunting for a vintage treasure or updating a seasonal wardrobe. The shop’s ever-changing inventory keeps locals and visitors coming back for more.

Nest Furnishings in Avon brings sophistication and creativity to the consignment furniture scene. The store’s spacious showroom features a mix of modern and classic pieces, from statement sofas to finely crafted décor items. Nest Furnishings also offers interior design services, helping clients reimagine their homes with curated style. Every item reflects a balance of form and function, making Nest a trusted destination for those looking to refresh their living spaces sustainably.

The Thrifty Shop in Edwards is a local favorite for affordable finds that support a good cause. Operated by Vail Valley Cares, the store’s proceeds go directly back into the community through grants and assistance programs. Shoppers can explore an expansive selection of clothing, furniture, books, and household goods, knowing their purchases help others in need. It’s a place where generosity and thrift come together under one roof.

Habitat ReStore Vail Valley in Gypsum offers shoppers a chance to discover unique furniture, building materials, and home accessories—all while supporting Habitat for Humanity’s mission. The store gives new life to gently used items and diverts tons of materials from landfills each year. With an inventory that changes daily, the ReStore attracts DIYers, decorators, and bargain hunters alike who want to make sustainable choices while improving their homes.

The Home Outpost in Gypsum combines the warmth of a boutique with the variety of a consignment warehouse. The store carries furniture, art, and décor that blend rustic mountain sensibilities with refined style. Its layout feels like an interior design showcase, inspiring visitors with creative ways to reimagine their spaces. The Home Outpost’s approachable team and curated selection have earned it a loyal following among design-minded locals.

Thanks, ChatGPT.